RUS | ENG

ISSN 2658-3828 (print)
ISSN 2658-6665 (online)

A.G. Kozintsev. On the origin of certain Early Iron Age populations of Western Siberia. Part II . Diachronic analysis

 Download  |  Go to Issue #1. 2025

 

A.G. Kozintsev - Peter the Great Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography (the Kunstkamera)
of the Russian Academy of Sciences,
St. Petersburg, Russian Federation
E-mail: alexanderkozintsev @ yandex.ru
ORCID: 0000-0002-0165-8109

 

Abstract

Fourteen measurements of ten male Early Iron Age cranial samples from Western Siberia — early Bol’shaya Rechka (Zavyalovskaya), three Kamen’, three Sargat, Gorokhovo, Kashino, and Kulay — were compared with those of 28 Bronze Age samples from Western Siberia and other areas using the D2 distance measure corrected for sample size. The D2 matrix was subjected to nonmetric multidimensional scaling and cluster analysis. Results suggest that all analyzed groups except early Bol’shaya Rechka and Kulay were likely descendants of local Late Bronze Age populations, which had originated through admixture between earlier Western Siberian autochthones and Andronovo immigrants. The early Bol’shaya Rechka group from Bobrovka, while resembling people of the Kamenny Log stage of Karasuk culture, could, like the latter, have originated via admixture between Andronovans and people of Okunev culture. Three Kamen’ groups, which are close to each other, contrast with early Bol’shaya Rechka, displaying a markedly Kulay (or aboriginal Baraba) tendency. Also, they included a Saka component. Sargat might have originated from Irmen’. The Gorokhovo sample is indistinguishable from Sargat. Kashino resembles the Late Bronze Age (possibly Begazy-Dandybai) group from Yelovka I. Kulay is close to the aborigines of Baraba. Their relatives had been displaced from the forest-steppe to the taiga or the Altai-Sayan highland (Kopto, Kara-Koba culture). Others, like the southern Kulay people, eventually returned from the taiga to the forest-steppe. If they were Samoyeds, then the admixed groups which had displaced them were mostly Ugrian or Indo-Iranian speakers. The early Bol’shaya Rechka people resemble those of the late (Kamenny Log) stage of the Karasuk culture. They could have spoken a Yeniseian or, because the influence of Andronovo increased at the Kamenny Log stage, an Indo-Iranian language. But if the Bol’shaya Rechka people were Yeniseian speakers, which is quite probable, then those of Kulay, who are quite dissimilar to them, must have spoken a different language — likely Samoyed.

 

Key words: craniometry, Western Siberia, Bronze Age, Early Iron Age, Samoyeds, Ugrians, Yeniseians, multivariate analysis

 

UDC 572
DOI: 10.31250/2658-3828-2025-1-144-156

 

For citation: Kozintsev A.G. On the origin of certain Early Iron Age populations of Western Siberia. Part II. Diachronic analysis. Camera praehistorica. 2025, no. 1 (14), рр. 144–156. DOI: 10.31250/2658-3828-2025-1-144-156 (in Russian).

 

References


  • Alekseev, V.P., Gokhman, I.I., Tumen, D., Kratkii ocherk paleoantropologii Tsentral’noi Azii (kamennyi vek — epokha rannego zheleza) [A Brief Outline of Paleoanthropology of Central Asia (Stone Age — Early Iron Age)], Arkheologiia, etnografiia i antropologiia Mongolii, Novosibirsk: Nauka Publ., 1987, pp. 208–241, (in Russian).

  • Bagashev, A.N., Paleoantropologiia Zapadnoi Sibiri: Lesostep’ v epokhu rannego zheleza [Paleoanthropology of Western Siberia: The Forest-steppe in the Early Iron Age], Novosibirsk: Nauka Publ., 2000, 374 p., (in Russian).

  • Bagashev, A.N., Antropologiia Zapadnoi Sibiri [Anthropology of Western Siberia], Novosibirsk: Nauka Publ., 2017, 407 p., (in Russian).

  • Blažek, V., Yenisseian Homeland and Migrations, in: Man in India, 2017, vol. 97, no. 1, pp. 69–94.

  • Chikisheva, T.A., Dinamika antropologicheskoi differentsiatsii naseleniia iuga Zapadnoi Sibiri v epokhi neolita — rannego zheleza [Dynamics of Anthropological Differentiation of the Southwestern Siberian Population from the Neolithic to the Early Iron Age], Novosibirsk: IAETSO RANPubl., 2012, 467 p., (in Russian).

  • Chikisheva, T.A., Pozdnyakov, D.V., Antropologicheskie aspekty odinovskoi kul’tury (Zapadnaia Sibir’) [The Physical Anthropology of the Odino People, Western Siberia], Arheologiya, etnografiya i antropologiya Evrazii, 2019, vol. 47, no. 4, pp. 128–139, (in Russian).

  • Chindina, L.A., Drevniaia istoriia Srednego Priob’ia v epokhu zheleza. Kulaiskaia kul’tura [Ancient History of the Middle Ob in the Iron Age. The Kulay Culture], Tomsk: Tomsk State Universitet Publ., 1984, 255 p., (in Russian).

  • Chlenova, N.L., Sootnoshenie kul’tur karasukskogo tipa i ketskikh toponimov na territorii Sibiri [Relationship Between Karasuk Type Cultures and Ket Toponyms in Siberia], in: Proiskhozhdenie aborigenov Sibiri i ikh iazykov, Tomsk: Tomsk State Universitet Publ., 1969, pp. 143–146, (in Russian).

  • Chlenova, N.L., Datirovka irmenskoi kul’tury [Date of the Irmen Culture], in: Problemy khronologii i kul’turnoi prinadlezhnosti arkheologicheskikh pamiatnikov Zapadnoi Sibiri, Tomsk: Tomsk State Universitet Publ., 1970, pp. 133–150, (in Russian).

  • Flegontov, P., Changmai, P., Zidkova, A, Logacheva, M.D., Altınışık, N.E., … Tatarinova, T.V., Genomic Study of the Ket: A Paleo-Eskimo-related Ethnic Group with Significant Ancient North Eurasian Ancestry, Scientific Reports, 2016, no. 6, article no. 20768, DOI: 10.1038/srep20768.

  • Griaznov, M.P., Arkheologicheskoe issledovanie territorii odnogo drevnego poselka (raskopki Severno-altaiskoi ekspeditsii v 1949 g.) [An Archaeological Study of an Ancient Village (Excavations by the Northern Altai Expedition in 1949)], Kratkie soobshcheniia Instituta istorii material’noi kul’tury, 1951, vol. 40, pp. 105–113, (in Russian).

  • Dremov, V.A., Naselenie Verkhnego Priob’ia v epokhu bronzy (antropologicheskii ocherk) [The Bronze Age Population of the Upper Ob (Based on Cranial Data)], Tomsk: TGU Publ., 1997, 261 p., (in Russian).

  • Gromov, A.V., Proiskhozhdenie i sviazi okunevskogo naseleniia Minusinskoi kotloviny [Origins and Affinities of the Okunev Population of the Minusinsk Basin], in: Okunevskii sbornik. Kul’tura. Iskusstvo. Antropologiia, St.Petersburg: Petro-RIF Publ., 1997, pp. 301–345, (in Russian).

  • Helimski, E.A., Komparativistika, uralistika: Lektsii i stat’i [Comparative Linguistics, Uralian Studies. Lectures and Articles], Moscow: Iazyki russkoi kul’tury Publ., 2000, 640 p., (in Russian).

  • Kishkurno, M.S., Sleptsova, A.V., Novye dannye po odontologii naseleniia kulaiskoi kul’tury Novosibirskogo Piob’ia [New Data on the Dental Anthropology of the Kulay People of the Novosibirsk Stretch of the Ob’], Vestnik arkheologii, antropologii i etnografii, 2019, no. 4 (47), pp. 140–151, (in Russian).

  • Kozintsev, A.G., Kety, ural’tsy, “amerikanoidy”: integratsiia kraniometricheskikh i kranioskopicheskikh dannykh [Kets, Uralians, “Americanoids”: An Integration of Craniometric and Cranial Nonmetric Data], in: Paleoantropologiia, etnicheskaia antropologiia, etnogenez: K 75-letiiu Il’i Iosifovicha Gokhmana, St.Petersburg: MAE RANPubl., 2004, pp. 172–185, (in Russian).

  • Kozintsev, A.G., Osnovnye napravleniia populiatsionnoi dinamiki v Severnoi Evrazii ot mezolita do epokhi rannei bronzy (po dannym kraniologii i genetiki) [Patterns in the Population History of Northern Eurasia from the Mesolithic to the Early Bronze Age, Based on Craniometry and Genetics], Arheologiya, etnografiya i antropologiya Evrazii, 2021, vol. 49, no. 4, pp. 121–132, (in Russian).

  • Kozintsev, A.G., Proiskhozhdenie andronovtsev (statisticheskii podkhod) [Origin of the Andronovans: A Statistical Approach], Arheologiya, etnografiya i antropologiya Evrazii, 2023, vol. 51, no. 4, pp. 142–151, (in Russian).

  • Kozintsev, A.G., O proiskhozhdenii nekotorykh grupp naseleniia Zapadnoi Sibiri rannego zheleznogo veka. Chast’ I. Sinkhronnyi analiz [On the Origin of Certain Western Siberian Populations of the Early Iron Age. Part I. Synchronic Analysis], Camera Praehistorica, 2024, no. 2, pp. 140–157, (in Russian).

  • Matveeva, N.P., Sargatskaia kul’tura na srednem Tobole [The Sargat Culture on the Middle Tobol], Novosibirsk: Nauka Publ., 1993, 175 p., (in Russian).

  • Matveeva, N.P., Rannii zheleznyi vek Priishim’ia [The Early Iron Age of the Ishim Drainage], Novosibirsk: Nauka Publ., 1994, 152 p., (in Russian).

  • Moiseyev, V.G., Kranioskopicheskaia kharakteristika naseleniia Zapadnoi i Iuzhnoi Sibiri skifskogo vremeni [Nonmetric Traits in Early Iron Age Cranial Series from Western and Southern Siberia], Arheologiya, etnografiya i antropologiya Evrazii, 2006, no. 1 (25), pp. 145–152, (in Russian).

  • Napol’skikh, V.V., Vvedenie v istoricheskuiu uralistiku [Introduction to Uralic Studies], Izhevsk: Ural'skii Institut istorii, iazyka i literatury Publ., 1997, 268 p., (in Russian).

  • Papin, D.V., Bol'sherechenskaia kul'tura [Bol’shaya Rechka Culture], in: Istoriia Altaia, vol. 1, Barnaul: Altai State Universitet Publ., 2019, pp. 210–219, (in Russian).

  • Polos’mak, N.V., Kul’turnaia prinadlezhnost’ gorokhovskoi gruppy pamiatnikov [The Cultural Attribution of the Gorokhovo Group of Sites], Kratkie soobshcheniia Instituta arkheologii, 1986, no. 186, pp. 29–33, (in Russian).

  • Polos’mak, N.V., Baraba v epokhu rannego zheleza [Baraba in the Early Iron Age], Novosibirsk: Nauka Publ., 1987, 144 p., (in Russian).

  • Rykushina, G.V., Paleoantropologiia karasukskoi kul’tury [Paleoanthropology of the Karasuk Culture], Moscow: Staryi Sad Publ., 2007, 198 p., (in Russian).

  • Shevchenko, A.V., Antropologicheskaia kharakteristika naseleniia cherkaskul’skoi kul’tury i voprosy ego etnogeneza [Anthropological Characteristics of the Cherkaskul’ Population and Problems of its Origin], in: Sovremennye problemy i novye metody v antropologii, Leningrad: Nauka Publ., 1980, pp. 163–183, (in Russian).

  • Solodovnikov, K.N., Kraniologicheskie materialy iz mogil’nika andronovskoi kul’tury Firsovo XIVv svete problem formirovaniia naseleniia Verkhnego Priob’ia v epokhu bronzy [Cranial Materials from the Andronovo Era Cemetery Firsovo XIV, with Reference to the Origin of the Bronze Age Upper Ob’ Population], in: Izuchenie istoriko-kul’turnogo naslediia narodov Iuzhnoi Sibiri, Gorno-Altaisk: AKINPubl., 2005, vol. 1, pp. 47–75, (in Russian).

  • Solodovnikov, K.N., Sviazi naseleniia kazakhstanskikh stepei i Altaiskogo regiona v epokhu bronzy po dannym paleoantropologii [Affinities of the Kazakhstanian Steppe and Altai Population in the Bronze Age, Based on Cranial Data], in: Izuchenie istoriko-kul’turnogo naslediia Tsentral’noi Evrazii. Margulanovskie chteniia–2008, Karaganda, 2009, pp. 158–164, (in Russian).

  • Solodovnikov, K.N., Rykun, M.P., Materialy k antropologii pakhomovskoi kul’tury epokhi bronzy Zapadnoi Sibiri [Materials on the Anthropology of the Bronze Age Pakhomovo Culture of Western Siberia], Vestnik antropologii, 2011, no. 19, pp. 112–129, (in Russian).

  • Solodovnikov, K.N., Tur, S.S., Kraniologicheskie materialy eluninskoi kul’tury epokhi rannei bronzy Verkhnego Priob’ia [Cranial Materials on the Early Bronze Age Yelunino Culture, the Upper Ob’], in: Kiriushin Iu.F., Grushin S.P., Tishkin A.A., Pogrebal’nyi obriad naseleniia epokhi rannei bronzy Verkhnego Priob’ia (po materialam gruntovogo mogil’nika Teleutskii Vzvoz I, Barnaul: Altai State Universitet Publ., 2003, pp. 142–176, (in Russian).

  • Troitskaia, T.N., Zubova, A.V., K voprosu o naselenii kulaiskogo mogil’nika Kamennyi Mys [People Buried at the Kulay Cemetery Kamennyi Mys], in: Kul’tura kak sistema v istoricheskom kontekste: Opyt Zapadno-Sibirskikh arkheologicheskikh soveshchanii. Materialy XV Mezhdunarodnoi Zapadno-Sibirskoi arkheologicheskoi konferentsii, Tomsk: Agraf-Press Publ., 2010, pp. 83–85, (in Russian).

  • Tur, S.S., Solodovnikov, K.N., Novye kraniologicheskie materialy iz pogrebenii karakol’skoi kul’tury epokhi bronzy Gornogo Altaia [New Cranial Materials from the Bronze Age Karakol Burials in Gorny Altai], in: Izuchenie istoriko-kul’turnogo naslediia narodov Iuzhnoi Sibiri, vol. 1, Gorno-Altaisk: AKINPubl., 2005, pp. 35–47, (in Russian).

  • Volkov, V.G., Drevnie migratsii samodiitsev i eniseitsev v svete geneticheskikh dannykh [Prehistoric Migrations of Samoyeds and Yeniseians in the Light of Genetic Data], Tomskii zhurnal lingvisticheskikh i antropologicheskikh issledlvanii, 2013, vol. 1 (1), pp. 79–96, (in Russian).

  • Zubova, A.V., Naselenie Zapadnoi Sibiri vo II tysiacheletii do nashei ery (po antropologicheskim dannym) [Population of Western Siberia in the 2nd Millennium BC (Based on Anthropological Data], Novosibirsk: IAETSO RANPubl., 2014, 228 p., (in Russian).